What is a good love song for this situation?

A guy friend and I recently told each other that we had crushes on one another. Well our feelings started progressing really fast. Neither of us expected this to happen, so we decided that we aren't going to date just yet because of it all being so sudden. He had me listen to "Never Never Land" by Lyfe Jennings and told me that song was for me. I need one that I can dedicate to him. I've already listened to No Air and With You and Suffocate, but they don't seem to really fit the bill. Any suggestions?